Greeley collectors send us their cards instead of becoming part-time eBay sellers. We handle the photographing, the pricing, and the selling — your cards go live in an upcoming Whatnot show, in front of buyers who showed up ready to bid.
Not sure what that looks like? See how a live show runs before you send anything in.
Getting Your Cards To Us
Greeley sits roughly 55 miles from our home base — too far for routine pickup, but for the right collection we'll happily make the drive. Otherwise, tracked and insured shipping gets us there just as well.
Current Greeley Service Coverage
Greeley is served case by case for in-person collection pickup. We evaluate larger collections for travel and use tracked, insured shipping for smaller groups.
This is our current first-party service policy, not a directory listing. Pickup and travel are confirmed after we review the collection.
Whatever You're Sitting On
Broncos and Nuggets rookies, vintage inserts, graded slabs — if it has value, we'll get it in front of buyers. Colorado collectors follow all of these:
What You Keep
You're not locked into one flat rate — the split scales up with value: 60% under $50, 75% from $50 to $499, 85% at $500 and above. No cost to start, and shipping and packaging materials are on us. Full details are in our consignment terms.
How It Works
- Start with the consignment form — a quick rundown of what you're sending in.
- Greeley is close enough (~55 mi) that for the right collection, we'll drive out at no cost to you.
- We run comps, price it right, and slot it into an upcoming show.
- Payout hits within 10 business days of the sale.
We Also Serve
Consignors throughout the Front Range and beyond:
Ready to send in your cards?
Fill out the consignment form and we'll follow up to talk pricing, timing, and next steps.
Consign Your Cards