If you've got sports cards sitting in New York and you'd rather not spend your weekends photographing, listing, and shipping every single one, that's exactly what we handle. Send us your cards, we price them against real market comps, and they go live in an upcoming Whatnot show — in front of buyers who are already there to bid.
Not sure what that looks like? See how a live show runs before you send anything in.
Getting Your Cards To Us
New York is well outside our driving radius, so consignment works by mail: ship your cards in with tracked, insured shipping, and once they land we handle inspection, pricing, staging, and the live show from there. For exceptional collections, we'll also consider travel — just ask.
Whatever You're Sitting On
Yankees and Mets rookies, vintage inserts, graded slabs — if it has value, we'll get it in front of buyers. Colorado collectors follow all of these:
What You Keep
Our split gets better as your cards do — 60% on anything under $50, 75% on $50–$499, and 85% on $500 and up. No upfront cost, and we cover all shipping and packaging materials once a card sells. Full details are in our consignment terms.
How It Works
- Fill out the consignment form — tell us what you've got.
- New York consignors ship in with tracked, insured shipping — we handle everything from there.
- It gets priced against real comps, staged, and queued for an upcoming show.
- You get paid within 10 business days of it selling.
Ready to send in your cards?
Fill out the consignment form and we'll follow up to talk pricing, timing, and next steps.
Consign Your Cards