Pueblo collectors send us their cards instead of becoming part-time eBay sellers. We handle the photographing, the pricing, and the selling — your cards go live in an upcoming Whatnot show, in front of buyers who showed up ready to bid.
Not sure what that looks like? See how a live show runs before you send anything in.
Getting Your Cards To Us
Pueblo consignors work with us entirely by mail — ship your cards in tracked and insured, and we take it from there: inspection, pricing against real comps, staging, and a spot in an upcoming show. For a big enough collection, travel isn't off the table either.
Current Pueblo Service Coverage
Pueblo consignments normally arrive by tracked, insured shipping. Exceptional larger collections can be reviewed individually before deciding whether travel makes sense.
This is our current first-party service policy, not a directory listing. Pickup and travel are confirmed after we review the collection.
Whatever You're Sitting On
Broncos and Nuggets rookies, vintage inserts, graded slabs — if it has value, we'll get it in front of buyers. Colorado collectors follow all of these:
What You Keep
The more your cards are worth, the more of that value you keep — 60/40 under $50, 75/25 from $50–$499, and 85/15 at $500 and up, all in your favor. Nothing upfront, and we cover shipping and materials out of our cut. Full details are in our consignment terms.
How It Works
- Fill out the consignment form — tell us what you've got.
- Pueblo consignors ship in with tracked, insured shipping — we handle everything from there.
- It gets priced against real comps, staged, and queued for an upcoming show.
- You get paid within 10 business days of it selling.
We Also Serve
Consignors throughout the Front Range and beyond:
Ready to send in your cards?
Fill out the consignment form and we'll follow up to talk pricing, timing, and next steps.
Consign Your Cards